Our Two Rough Cuts of 'The Hurst'

This is the first rough cut of our thriller, this version has most of the original footage and is not heavily edited. The second rough cut below contrasts the first by being edited significantly and it includes many effects.

Our Questions To You...
1. We would like to know which one you think is the best version?

2. We would also like to know which one, out of the two rough cuts, you think would gain the most marks?

3. Our last question would be your general opinion on the micro and macro elements of our Thriller?